Cross-cultural differences in strategic risky decisions in baseball among professional baseball teams in North America and Japan: European American participants preferred high risk-high payoff strategies

Swinging for the Fences Versus Advancing the Runner: Culture, Motivation, and Strategic Decision Making. Roxie Chuang et al. Social Psychological and Personality Science, March 19, 2021. https://doi.org/10.1177/1948550621999273

Abstract: This research investigated cross-cultural differences in strategic risky decisions in baseball—among professional baseball teams in North America and Japan (Study 1) and among baseball fans in the United States and Japan (Study 2—preregistered). Study 1 analyzed archival data from professional baseball leagues and demonstrated that outcomes reflecting high risk-high payoff strategies were more prevalent in North America, whereas outcomes reflecting low risk-low payoff strategies were more prevalent in Japan. Study 2 investigated fans’ strategic decision making with a wider range of baseball strategies as well as an underlying reason for the difference: approach/avoidance motivational orientation. European American participants preferred high risk-high payoff strategies, Japanese participants preferred low risk-low payoff strategies, and this cultural variation was explained by cultural differences in motivational orientation. Baseball, which exemplifies a domain where strategic decision making has observable consequences, can demonstrate the power of culture through the actions and preferences of players and fans alike.

Keywords: decision making, culture, motivation, risk-taking